Spread the love

A survey was conducted to know the impact of Consumer Protection Act,1986 provisions with respect to medical negligence cases in the form of questionnaire. Set of questionnaire were distributed among the panel of Doctors, Judges, General Public and NGOs.


I am trying to give a critical analysis/response of the said survey in nutshell:


Among panel of judges 118 responses are recorded, 210 responses from the Doctors, 80 responses from the public and 3 responses from NGOs.


 As per question no.1 which speaks about the increase in medical negligence cases in consumer fora, 72% of the judges answered in affirmative and 29% answered in negative.

As regards question no.2 is concerned wherein it was asked, whether hospitals including those run by the Govt. or Charitable institute should be held liable under the Consumer Protection Act, 1986, 91% answered positively. In other words, as per their responses Govt. or Charitable Institution should also be held liable for medical negligence; however, 9% of the judges hold the view that such Hospital should not be held liable because Govt. or Charitable Institution provides services to the patient free of charge/nominal charges.

Further, approx. 58% of the Judges hold the view that medical negligence cases should be adjudicated/decided in a summary manner; however 42% of the Judges thinks that these kinds of cases should be adjudicated by the civil courts through proper appreciation of evidence.

Meanwhile, it was asked in question no. 4 whether a special training should be accorded to the members in Consumer Fora regarding medical negligencecases, 82 % of the judges responded positively while 18% of the judges dissented to this view that special training should be imparted to the members.

In question no.5 it was asked whether quantum of compensation as awarded for medical negligence is adequate, 55% of the judges answered YES while 45% of the judges said NO.

As per the Survey we got 70% of the judges hold the view that medical expert opinion is easily accessible in medical negligence cases while 30% of the judges do not think that expert opinion helps a lot the member concerned of the Consumer Fora in deciding the issue of medical negligence.

More than 50% of the judges think that medical expert opinion sometimes work as self-serving evidence in favour of the Doctors involved in the cases of medical negligence. According to them decisions on the basis of medical expert opinion violates the principle of natural justice.

It was also observed that approx. 60% of the judges feel, there is a need of medical professional (Doctor) as a member in the Consumer forum/Commission to decide the medical negligence matter while 40% do not feel the necessity of medical professional (Doctor) as a member in the Consumer Forum.

Furthermore, more than half of the majority responses as received from the judges it was found that there should be separate tribunals exclusively to decide medical negligence cases.

Last but not the least, when a query was put to the judges that Consumer Protection Act,1986 is effective in dealing with the cases of medical negligence, 86% responses were positive in nature while 14% opined that CPA is not that much effective in dealing with medical negligence cases.



No doubt, there is increase in the medical negligence cases in the Consumer Forum in the present scenario which shows that the consumer are getting redressal of their grievance in the form of awarded compensation through Consumer Fora/Commission by holding Doctors/Hospital Concerned guilty of Deficiency in services or medical negligence.
No fruitful result is available to the victim of the medical negligence cases, as the matter involves complicated question of law and facts which sometimes become difficult to be adjudicated in a summary manner. At worst situation, the outcome of the Consumer Fora may be wrong sometimes to decide these kinds of cases due to lack of medical jurisprudence among the members.
Since the Govt. Hospital or Charitable Institution provides services keeping in view the welfare of the public as their main objective and that too free of charge or by charging nominal fees. So exclusion of such Hospitals from the array of respondents is desirable, reason being if no negligence is proved on their part after no. of years, the very purpose/objective of running Govt. Hospital would be defeated as the Govt. would be reluctant to provide free medical services to the general public.The demerit of not including the Govt. Hospital or Charitable Institution in the array of Opposite Parties just on the plea that they do not provide services for consideration would be fatal as it would put an umbrella on the said Institution by performing their services negligently. Moreover it is observed that in general parlance Doctors of Govt. or Charitable Institution least bothered to treat their patient properly as they have the impression of getting a pre fixed salary/honorarium from the Govt. even if they remain negligent or careless in rendering services to their patients/ concerned consumers.
Since the judicial members or members from Administrative background are not well versed with the technicalities of the medical cases, so special training to those members to adjudicate the medical negligence matter would prove effective.But on the other side if we look into the working of the Consumer Fora system, the adjudicating concerned member holding the chair are already burdened with the quantum of cases/matters and they hardly got time to impart or get such sort of special training especially w.r.t. medical negligence cases. Moreover, such sort of special training would increase pendency of cases in the Commission which is the greatest lacuna of our judicial system. And the very purpose of CPA of adjudicating the cases by summary trial would be defeated.
Generally the victim of medical negligence cases are reluctant to sue the Doctors/Hospitals in Civil Courts, reason being delayed decision. As common saying we know –JUSTICE DELAYED IS JUSTICE DENIED So, adjudication of the Medical Negligence cases through summary trial where the victims/complainant got justice expeditiously andredressal of their grievance in the form of awarded compensation .It maintains the faith of the people in the judicial system that they will surely get justice. Moreover, no as such legal procedure technicalities are involved in filing a consumer complaint in comparison to filing of a suit before Civil Court.However, in practicality it could be seen that member concerned of the Commission are not well versed with the medical sciences/ terminology and therefore sometimes it took more than 10 years for a just decision in medical negligence cases. And even when on appreciation of evidence after such a long time the decision in favour of the complainant or the respondents would somehow defeat the faith of the parties on the judicial system due to the fact that they already got harassed by putting appearance on N nos. of dates of hearing and there would be no calculation w.r.t. to the litigation expenses which both the parties were bound to bear. Furthermore, it would hamper the goodwill of the parties concerned against whom complaint was filed and at the end against whom the award was given by the Commission.
As we know, the death of any member of a family and loss as a consequence could not be reimbursed in monetary terms. But punishing a Doctor/Hospital for their medical negligence and awarding compensation would somehow help the victim family financially and it would prove as deterrent on the Doctors/Hospital who will think twice while treating their patient without following standard protocols and professional ethics.Awarding quantum of compensation in my view would not be that much helpful in reduction of medical negligence on the part of the negligent Doctors/Hospital concerned, they might feel to pay that awarded compensation be paid by their authorities in the form of vicarious liabilities and they’ll continue their ill practices. Rather some sort of imprisonment or criminal liability should be imposed on them who are negligent in their professional actso thatsuch sort of negligence which could even take away the life of the patient be repeated.
Appointment of medical expert member in the Consumer Fora/Commission is a dire need of the Commission to adjudicate the medical negligence cases in a just and proper manner.NO NEGATIVE IMPACT OF THIS POINT
It is necessary that separate tribunals be constituted to decide the matters of medical negligence effectively and the lacuna of delayed decision in said matters could be carved out.As far as constitution of Separate Tribunals for medical negligence cases is concerned it is not that much desirable because the Commission already have medical expert members to decide the said cases effectively.


The conduct of such sort of survey no doubt proves fruitful to look into the matters of medical negligence cases and to remove the defects from the judicial system.

As per my opinion, it is necessary that more number of medical expert members be appointed in the Consumer Forum/Commission to adjudicate the medical negligence cases because they are well versed with the medical terminology/technicalities and they are able to appreciate the medical literatures and case sheet/ summary of the complainant or the victim much better or in effective manner in comparison to members of non-medical background.

A special training programme should be conducted for the non-medical members but that too without prejudice to the routine office work of the members, so that in the absence of medical expert members they could be able to decide the medical negligence cases in just manner by appreciating the medical evidences.

It is nowhere disputed that medical negligence case takes much time for the outcome of the final decision due to the fact that members of the Commission are not well versed with the medical terms and complicated question of law and facts involves in those cases in comparison to other consumer complaints.

But in my view a reasonable time period/limit should be fixed within which the decision should be given by the concerned bench of the Consumer Foras/Commission where cases are put up. On the expiry of such period and after taking the reasons from the member of the said bench for not deciding the case within time limit, mattershould be transferred to the bench dealing with medical negligencecases as per the directions of the Presiding Member of the Consumer Fora/Commission.

Members of the Consumer Fora/Commission should have access to the medical journal and a regular medical negligence law reporter should be provided to them.

There should be a panel of Doctor to be appointed by the Department to assist the members in appreciating the evidence w.r.t. medical negligence cases so that said cases should be decided easily and expeditiously.

Lastly, I would emphasise that the complaint should be maintainable against the Govt./Charitable Institution and they should also be held liable for medical negligence cases, if any and for this purpose necessary amendments should be made in the definition of consumer u/s. 2(i)(d) of the Act by incorporating Govt. Hospitals as exception to the concept of availing free consideration service which put the complainant outside the purview of consumer in the Consumer Protection Act, 1986.

Moreover, campaign for consumer awareness programme should be organised to impart knowledge and relevant informationamong general public about their rights as a consumer and the benevolent provisions of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986.

Medical Ethics be made as a part of the Consumer Protection Act, 1986 to understand the matters of medical negligence cases in the curriculum subject of the law students.

I think that a panel of NGOs be constituted and established at every recognised Hospitals so that the victim or the complainant could easily approach them for redressal of their grievance directly to them instead of Consumer Fora/Commission and NGOs should filed complaint on behalf of the victims/complainant especially the illiterate ones.

Further, I think that some sort of medical expertise in the form of legal aid be provided to the complainant of medical negligence cases so that victims being a layman would be able to represent his/her case in a proper manner.

Also Read – How to remain Fit & Fine in this current time


  1. What’s up?

    I found this article very interesting…please read!

    Do you remember the blockbuster hit film The Matrix that was released in 1999? You may not know this, but it has deep spiritual implications concerning the times we are living in and Bible prophecy.

    It tells a story of how these “agents” are trying to turn us into machines. We are closer then ever before for this to become a reality when they cause us to receive an implantable microchip in our body during a time when physical money will be no more.

    You may have seen on NBC news concerning the implantable RFID microchip that some people are getting put in their hand to make purchases, but did you know this microchip matches perfectly with prophecy in the Bible?

    “He (the false prophet who deceives many by his miracles) causes all, both small and great, rich and poor, free and slave, to receive a mark on their right hand or on their foreheads, and that no one may buy or sell except one who has the mark or the name of the beast, or the number of his name…

    You also may have heard of the legendary number “666” that people have been speculating for possibly thousands of years on what it actually means. This article shares something I haven’t seen before, and I don’t think there could be any better explanation for what it means to calculate 666. This is no hoax. Very fascinating stuff!

    …Here is wisdom. Let him who has understanding calculate the number of the beast, for it is the number of a man: His number is 666″ (Revelation 13:16-18 NKJV).

    To see all the details showing why the Bible foretold of all these things, check out this article!


    GOD is sending out His end time warning:

    “Then a third angel followed them, saying with a loud voice, ‘If anyone worships the beast and his image, and receives his mark on his forehead or on his hand, he himself shall also drink of the wine of the wrath of God, which is poured out full strength into the cup of His indignation. He shall be tormented with fire and brimstone in the presence of the holy angels and in the presence of the Lamb. And the smoke of their torment ascends forever and ever; and they have no rest day or night, who worship the beast and his image, and whoever receives the mark of his name'” (Revelation 14:9-11).

    In the Islamic religion they have man called the Mahdi who is known as their messiah of whom they are waiting to take the stage. There are many testimonies from people online who believe this man will be Barack Obama who is to be the biblical Antichrist based off dreams they have received. I myself have had strange dreams about him like no other person. So much so that I decided to share this information.

    He came on stage claiming to be a Christian with no affiliation to the Muslim faith…

    “In our lives, Michelle and I have been strengthened by our Christian faith. But there have been times where my faith has been questioned — by people who don’t know me — or they’ve said that I adhere to a different religion, as if that were somehow a bad thing,” – Barack Obama

    …but was later revealed by his own family members that he indeed is a devout Muslim.

    So what’s in the name? The meaning of someones name can say a lot about a person. God throughout history has given names to people that have a specific meaning tied to their lives. How about the name Barack Obama? Let us take a look at what may be hiding beneath the surface…

    “And He (Jesus) said to them (His disciples), ‘I saw Satan fall like lightning from heaven'” (Luke 10:18).

    In the Hebrew language we can uncover the meaning behind the name Barack Obama.

    Barack, also transliterated as Baraq, in Hebrew is: lightning

    baraq – Biblical definition:

    From Strongs H1299; lightning; by analogy a gleam; concretely a flashing sword: – bright, glitter (-ing, sword), lightning. (Strongs Hebrew word H1300 baraq baw-rawk’)

    Barak ‘O’bamah, The use of bamah is used to refer to the “heights” of Heaven.

    bamah – Biblical definition:

    From an unused root (meaning to be high); an elevation: – height, high place, wave. (Strongs Hebrew word H1116 bamah baw-maw’)

    The day following the election of Barack Obama (11/04/08), the winning pick 3 lotto numbers in Illinois (Obama’s home state) for 11/5/08 were 666.

    Obama was a U.S. senator for Illinois, and his zip code was 60606.

    Seek Jesus while He may be found…repent, confess and forsake your sins and trust in the savior! Jesus says we must be born again by His Holy Spirit to enter the kingdom of God…God bless!

  2. What抯 Happening i’m new to this, I stumbled upon this I’ve found It positively useful and it has aided me out loads. I hope to contribute & assist other users like its helped me. Good job.

  3. Pingback: Important dates of DECEMBER 2020: क्यों और कौनसा दिन है महत्वपूर्ण?
  4. The cleaning firm accomplishes cleansing of areas of numerous sizes and also setups.

    The business’s professionals give cleaning with the aid of modern innovations, have unique equipment, as well as likewise have actually accredited detergents in their arsenal. Along with the above benefits, white wines use: desirable prices; cleansing in a short time; top quality outcomes; greater than 100 positive testimonials. Cleaning up offices will help maintain your work environment in order for the most efficient job. Any type of firm is extremely important atmosphere in the team. Cleansing services that can be ordered inexpensively now can aid to prepare it and provide a comfy space for labor.

    If needed, we leave cleaning up the kitchen area 2-3 hrs after placing the order. You obtain cleaning immediately.

    We provide professional maids new york for private clients. Utilizing European devices and licensed tools, we achieve maximum outcomes as well as provide cleaning quickly.

    We provide discounts for those who make use of the solution for the very first time, as well as positive terms of teamwork for routine customers.

    Our pleasant team provides you to get accustomed with positive regards to teamwork for corporate customers. We sensibly approach our activities, tidy making use of specialist cleansing products as well as specific devices. Our employees are educated, have clinical books and are familiar with the nuances of getting rid of complex and hard-to-remove dust from surface areas.

    We supply top quality cleansing for big ventures and also tiny companies of different instructions, with a discount rate of approximately 25%.

  5. Our employees make unique design , and of course with we pay close preference to standards safety and functionality. We are working with customer on all, without exception stages commit multilateral analysis of features rooms ,perform advance counts . In the event of appearances questions .
    Affordable kitchen renovations perhaps the same labor-intensive event in townhouse
    In the firm General Partnership NIOR Williamsbridge work masters, exactly they all know about Basement kitchen renovation.
    The Specialized Company provides quality Small home kitchen remodel by democratic prices . Masters with great practical experience work can help completely remake in a few weeks perform affordable price repair . The price depends on selected style of kitchen.

    Each room apartments, houses, cottages or other housing Port Richmond unique and carries its own high-functional load. And this setting especially is related to modern kitchens.

    Trailer kitchen remodel Fort Greene – kitchen renovation new york

  6. Hello! We those who make your daily life much easier . Our organization that gives you massage . – Russian New Yourk
    Distinctive unusuality our Thai salon is not an enforced setting. We advertise groups in a social network to optimize.
    Provide all of you check different type massage methods today. We we are waiting you in our salon.

  7. по ссылке
    – одна из самых популярных букмекерок по приему ставок на спорт. Букмекер имеет расширенную линию событий. Компания активно заключает ставки и проводит различные акции. Вся детальная информация доступна на главном сайте.

    Линия событий на веб-сайте – настоящая гордость. Чем шире линия, тем больше спортивных событий БК освещает. Сегодня игрокам доступно категорий, но это количество регулярно растет. Среди представленных доступны популярные виды дисциплин (футбол, волейбол, баскетбол) и только набирающие популярность дисциплины (сквош, троттинг).
    на сайте
    дает возможность делать ставки почти на все существующие спортивные дисциплины. Линия состоит из большого списка различных видов спорта. Туда входят события не только высшей лиги, но и небольшие турниры.

  8. В
    бк 1xbet
    прекрасно представляют, чем является остервенение, и словно, койкогда хочется встряхнуть дни адреналиновыми моментами. Для этого доступна разночтение игры без регистрации. И, само собой, вы сможете делать ставки для реальные деньги.

    Начинайте любую игру в бесплатном режиме, играйте платно и получайте выигрыши — самые мощные азартные впечатления ждут в
    для этом сайте

  9. Многочисленные из скважин по завершении мероприятия восстановительного комплекса событий имеют все шансы быть снова введены в эксплуатацию. Тем более что итоговая стоимость этих работ в десятки раз ниже цены самих сооружений.
    Обеспечено повышение дебита водозаборной скважины не менее 30 процентов от существующего на момент старта действий.

    В 80 процентах случаях скважины восстанавливаются до основных данных при включении в применение скважины, это по праву является альтернативой производства буровых работ новой скважины.

    Сотрудники нашей фирмы по Очистке КНС (Канализационно-насосная станция) и Увеличение производительности (дебита) водозаборных скважин предлагаем свои услуги всем, как частным так и общественным объединениям.

    Спецводсервис : оборудование для телеинспекции

  10. Wow that was unusual. I just wrote an incredibly long comment but after I clicked submit my comment didn’t show up. Grrrr… well I’m not writing all that over again. Anyhow, just wanted to say great blog!

  11. Thanks for your submission. Another point is that to be a photographer involves not only problems in catching award-winning photographs but hardships in getting the best digital camera suited to your requirements and most especially hardships in maintaining the standard of your camera. This is very correct and apparent for those professional photographers that are in to capturing this nature’s eye-catching scenes : the mountains, the forests, the actual wild or maybe the seas. Visiting these exciting places surely requires a camera that can surpass the wild’s nasty conditions.

  12. виза инвестора eb 5
    Как заработать денежные средства, вкладывая в жилплощадь?
    Выкупаем предназначенные для жилья помещения и квартиры, которые за долги выставляются на продажу на аукционах.
    Почему люди инвестируют данную сферу ? Одна из них, почему некоторые любят флиппинг, – это конечно шанс получения выгоды. Если собственность приобретается и ремонтируется по довольно низкой цене, а перепродается по намного более очень высокой стоимости.
    Корпорация работает с покупкой активов недвижимости, давая шанс одним избавляться от долговых обязательств, а прочим успешно заработать на всем этом.
    Вам не нужно совершать все это в одиночку.Мы здесь, для того чтобы оказать содействие.

    Строительство недвижимости в сша

  13. Yet another issue is that video gaming became one of the all-time biggest forms of fun for people of every age group. Kids participate in video games, plus adults do, too. The particular XBox 360 is amongst the favorite video games systems for those who love to have a lot of games available to them, and also who like to play live with other individuals all over the world. Thank you for sharing your notions.

  14. It’s best to participate in a contest for the most effective blogs on the web. I will suggest this web site!

  15. The things i have often told individuals is that while searching for a good online electronics shop, there are a few factors that you have to factor in. First and foremost, you should make sure to look for a reputable and reliable shop that has got great critiques and ratings from other consumers and marketplace analysts. This will ensure you are handling a well-known store that provides good assistance and aid to its patrons. Many thanks for sharing your ideas on this website.

  16. строительство домов в сша видео
    Вам не нужно совершать все это в одиночку.Мы здесь, для того чтобы оказать содействие.
    Флиппинг-вкладчик капитала время от времени покупает дома, а потом реализовывает их с намерением извлечения выгоды. С тем чтобы жилплощадь числилось активом, его надлежит приобретать с намерением быстро перепродать. Промежуток времени между приобретением и перепродажей зачастую образует от пары месяцев и до одного года.
    Почему люди инвестируют данную сферу ? Одна из них, почему некоторые любят флиппинг, – это конечно шанс получения выгоды. Если собственность приобретается и ремонтируется по довольно низкой цене, а перепродается по намного более очень высокой стоимости.
    Корпорация работает с покупкой активов недвижимости, давая шанс одним избавляться от долговых обязательств, а прочим успешно заработать на всем этом.
    Выкуп жилья – известный метод долгосрочного инвестирования, так же – если вы абсолютно всё оформите удачно – тогда вы сумеете успешно заработать реальные средства!

    книги про инвестирование в недвижимость

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *